Is it really true that some dogs are better off in one-dog-only families? My spouse really wants to get a new puppy but my 7 pound senior mini pin mix just doesn’t do so hot with other dogs in her space or interacting with her people. It’s not that I ever think it’d be a dangerous environment for a puppy but definitely an incovience for everyone who just wants a peaceful house. My spouse insists that they can both be trained to get along but I just don’t see that being the case?

Of course some dogs prefer to live alone! 

You could probably train or manage them to get along (either through reinforcing good interactions or a crate-and-rotate schedule), but if you don’t think it’s fair to your min pin, then don’t do it. If your dog is a senior and you think a puppy would cause some serious disruption and tension, it seems nicer to let your min pin live out the rest of her life as a single dog, and then get the puppy in a little while after she’s gone. 

It’s hard to convince spouses to put their desires on hold, especially if they’ve wanted a puppy for a long time, but I would just explain that you don’t think it’s fair to bring a puppy into a household with a single senior dog, when the senior dog prefers being alone. You could also mention that you (human) might end up resenting the puppy for the stress it causes your senior dog, and how that’s not fair to anyone involved and you would prefer to wait before getting a puppy.

I would definitely try to spin it as “it’s not fair to senior dog or to new puppy” more than “it can’t be trained”. Hopefully your spouse will be more open to waiting in that case. Good luck! -C